top of page

Are We Taxing the Speech Motor System Enough to Identify CAS?

Oct 14
10 min read

When Does Speech Break Down?

One of the questions I have been thinking about more and more is this:

At what point does a child’s speech motor system begin to break down?

Before we answer that question, we need to remember something important.


By around three years of age, children are generally expected to be approximately 75% intelligible to unfamiliar listeners. By around four years of age, they should be understood most of the time.


So when a five, six, seven or eight-year-old child comes into our clinic and even their parents need to interpret what they are saying, we already know something:

There is a significant problem.


Sometimes we become so focused on finding the correct diagnostic label that we lose sight of the problem sitting directly in front of us. The child is highly unintelligible. Their speech is not functioning as expected for their age, and their ability to communicate with other people is being affected.


That should make us stop and investigate.


We Already Know There Is a Problem


I often compare this to visiting a website that is not functioning properly.

You click on a page, but it will not open. You try another page and receive an error message. Images are missing and important information cannot be accessed.


You may not yet know whether the problem is the website’s coding, server, database or hosting provider. But you do not need to know the cause before recognising that something is wrong.


The website is not functioning as intended.


Speech assessment is similar.


When an older child remains highly unintelligible, we may not immediately know exactly why. But we already know there is a significant breakdown somewhere within the speech system.


Our job is to identify where that breakdown is occurring and what is causing it.


Some Children Can Say Many Words Clearly


The children I am thinking about are not necessarily children who cannot produce sounds, syllables or words.


In fact, many of them can accurately produce most one and two-syllable words.

They may even produce some three-syllable words without obvious difficulty, particularly when those words contain early-developing sounds and relatively simple syllable structures.


When asked to repeat an individual word during an assessment, they may listen carefully, watch the clinician’s face, think about the word and subtly slow their speech. With this additional attention and control, they may produce the word clearly.


If assessment stops at this level, it may be easy to conclude that speech motor planning is not the primary concern.


But everyday communication does not happen one carefully controlled word at a time.


Children do not receive a model before every word they say. They do not always have time to plan, rehearse and consciously control their speech.


They communicate in conversations.


They tell stories.


They explain their ideas.


They answer questions.


They participate in classroom discussions.


They read books containing increasingly complex vocabulary, multisyllabic words, later-developing sounds and complex consonant sequences, including three-element clusters.


They must produce those words within increasingly complex sentences while simultaneously organising their thoughts, generating language and communicating a message.


That places very different demands on the speech motor system.


What Happens When Speech Becomes Harder?


When a child produces a single word during an assessment, they can focus almost entirely on that word.


During connected speech, the child must formulate an idea, retrieve vocabulary, organise grammar, construct a sentence, plan and sequence speech movements, manage prosody and monitor whether the listener has understood.


All of this happens at the same time.


For some children, this is where their speech begins to change.


Speech becomes less precise.


Movement transitions become more difficult.


Multisyllabic words break down.


Later-developing sounds become less stable.


Complex consonant sequences become less accurate.


Stress and rhythm may change.


Intelligibility decreases.


This does not necessarily happen because the child does not know the word or cannot produce its individual sounds. The child may say the word clearly in isolation when given time to listen, think and carefully control the production.


The difficulty emerges when the child must access and sequence those movements automatically within longer, faster and more linguistically demanding speech.


Producing a complex word during direct imitation is not equivalent to producing that word while formulating a sentence and maintaining a conversation. Yet sometimes we place considerable diagnostic weight on the first task while giving insufficient attention to the second.

Are We Assessing Within the Child’s Comfort Zone?


Case and Grigos (2020) discussed how children with CAS may appear relatively consistent when an assessment does not adequately tax the speech motor system.


Static assessment methods using single-word responses may remain within a child’s speech production comfort zone. If this happens, the underlying motor speech difficulty or inconsistency may not fully emerge.


This raises an important clinical question:

Are we assessing the child at a level where speech is already successful, or have we increased the demands enough to locate the breakdown?


For some children, the difficulty is apparent in simple words.


For others, it emerges in longer multisyllabic words.


For some, it becomes clearer when later-developing sounds are embedded within increasingly complex word shapes.


For others, it may only become apparent during sentences, reading, narrative tasks or spontaneous conversation.


CAS does not necessarily reveal itself equally across every speaking task.


What Did the Original DEMSS Study Find?


Formal motor speech assessments provide valuable information and should form part of a comprehensive assessment.


However, a result indicating little or no evidence of CAS on one assessment does not automatically establish that the child therefore has an articulation or phonological disorder characterised by rule-based errors.


The findings from the original DEMSS validation study are especially relevant.


The DEMSS did not identify every child who had received a clinical diagnosis of CAS or mild CAS through a comprehensive assessment. Two children diagnosed with CAS and three children diagnosed with mild CAS were not identified by the DEMSS.

The authors suggested that this may reflect the fact that DEMSS was developed primarily for younger children and those with more severe speech impairments. Some children with milder difficulties may perform relatively well on the simpler DEMSS stimuli, yet demonstrate motor speech difficulties during more phonetically complex or multisyllabic tasks included in a comprehensive assessment.


The authors also described two children who were not identified by the DEMSS despite receiving a clinical diagnosis of CAS. These children demonstrated numerous vowel distortions in connected speech. Their performance during the isolated-word DEMSS task appeared to improve when they could watch the clinician’s face and directly imitate the model.


Groping and voicing errors were also observed during more difficult tasks but were not included in the DEMSS score.


These findings reinforce an important point:

A child may perform relatively well during a structured assessment while demonstrating much clearer motor speech difficulties when speech demands increase.


A Negative CAS Result Does Not End the Investigation


If a child does not meet criteria for CAS on a particular assessment, we should not automatically conclude that the explanation must be an articulation or phonological disorder.


This is also why experience in assessing childhood motor speech disorders matters. The American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA, 2007) emphasises that CAS assessment and diagnosis should be undertaken by a speech-language pathologist with specific experience in paediatric speech sound disorders, including motor speech disorders.


Recognising CAS requires more than administering a test; it requires knowing which speech characteristics to observe, how to interpret them, and when to investigate further.







Why Clinical Experience Matters in CAS Assessment


There is something else that I believe is incredibly important in the assessment of childhood apraxia of speech: the clinical experience of the speech pathologist.


When you have spent years listening to, assessing and treating children with CAS, you develop pattern recognition. You become increasingly familiar with the particular characteristics of their speech, how those characteristics interact, and how speech changes as demands increase.


Sometimes, an experienced clinician can listen to a child for just a few minutes and recognise features that immediately raise suspicion of CAS. That is not the same as making a diagnosis in five minutes, but it tells us where to direct our assessment.

I regularly speak with parents whose children have spent years receiving speech therapy without a clear diagnosis. Some have worked with five or six speech pathologists before reaching me. CAS may have been suspected along the way, but the clinician did not feel confident making the diagnosis. In other cases, the possibility of CAS had not been raised at all.


Meanwhile, these children may have spent years receiving intervention that did not adequately address their underlying speech motor difficulties.


And that concerns me, because diagnostic uncertainty should not mean delaying appropriate treatment.


If there is good reason to suspect CAS, we can begin incorporating evidence-informed motor-based treatment principles while continuing to assess and refine our clinical understanding. We do not necessarily need to wait until we are completely confident in the diagnostic label before addressing the child's suspected motor speech difficulties.


Of course, not every speech sound difficulty is caused by CAS. Our intervention still needs to be guided by careful differential assessment and the child's individual needs.


So how do speech pathologists develop the experience needed to recognise CAS?


One of my strongest recommendations is to watch and listen to as many examples of children with confirmed CAS speaking as you can.

If you don't have access to many children with CAS in your own clinical practice, seek out educational videos showing children with CAS across different ages, severity levels and speech tasks.


Listen carefully. What happens to vowel accuracy? Coarticulatory transitions? Prosody? Consistency? What changes when the child moves from single words to multisyllabic words, sentences and connected speech?


Whenever possible, learn from experienced clinicians who can explain what you are hearing and why it matters.


We need to train our ears, not just learn how to administer assessments.

Because ultimately, a test score is only one piece of information. The ability to recognise and interpret the child's speech characteristics is just as important.


If speech becomes less accurate as motor demands increase, we need to ask why.


Why can the child produce a word accurately when concentrating on it but not maintain that accuracy within a sentence?


Why does speech become increasingly difficult as utterance length increases?


Why do multisyllabic words containing later-developing sounds create disproportionate difficulty?


Why does intelligibility decrease during spontaneous conversation despite relatively successful performance on structured tasks?


Why does the child need increased attention, effort and control to maintain accuracy?


Most importantly:


Why does increasing motor load result in increasing speech breakdown?


Of course, increasing difficulty with longer or more complex speech is not, in itself, diagnostic of CAS. We still need to determine whether the breakdown reflects speech motor planning and programming difficulties, phonological or linguistic demands, or other contributing factors.


CAS is fundamentally a difficulty with planning and programming speech movement sequences and the transitions between those movements. Difficulty with coarticulation may become increasingly apparent as the child has to connect more complex movements across sounds, syllables, words and sentences.


That does not mean children with CAS can never demonstrate consistent or seemingly rule-based errors.


Many children referred for assessment have received years of therapy. Their errors may have become more consistent over time. They may have learnt particular words or movement sequences through repeated practice. They may also have developed strategies such as slowing down and consciously monitoring their speech.


A child who now presents with mild difficulties may have had severe CAS at two or three years of age. If earlier videos were available, they might reveal a very different presentation.

However, not every child with CAS begins with severe difficulties. Some children have mild, moderate or mild-to-moderate CAS from the outset.


Whatever the severity, we still need to identify where speech breaks down.


The Purpose Is to Locate the Breakdown


A comprehensive CAS assessment should locate the point at which the child’s speech begins to lose accuracy, automaticity, efficiency or stability.


Does the breakdown occur in simple words?


Does it emerge in multisyllabic words?


What happens when later-developing sounds are incorporated into longer word shapes?


What happens with complex consonant sequences?


What happens in sentences?


What happens during reading?


What happens when the child tells a story or explains an unfamiliar idea?


What happens during spontaneous conversation?


And perhaps most importantly:


What changes when the child can no longer devote all of their attention to carefully controlling one word at a time?


If we never increase the demands beyond the level at which the child is successful, we may never discover where the speech motor system begins to struggle.


Locating that breakdown is essential for diagnosis, but it is also essential for treatment planning.


A child who already produces most one and two-syllable words clearly does not need therapy focused only on those successful productions. Therapy must address the level at which speech is no longer accurate, automatic and stable.


We should not disregard what we hear in connected speech simply because it is not reflected in one assessment score.


We should not assume that a child must have an articulation or phonological disorder simply because one assessment did not identify CAS.

Instead, we need to ask whether we have adequately taxed the child’s speech motor system.


Because if speech only begins to break down when demands increase, that is exactly where assessment needs to look.


Perhaps the most important question is not:


“Can this child say the word?”


Perhaps it is:

“At what point does this child’s speech begin to break down?”


Because sometimes that is where CAS truly reveals itself.



Want to Go Deeper?


One of the most valuable ways to develop your ability to recognise childhood apraxia of speech is to watch and listen to children with CAS speaking — across different ages, severity levels and speaking tasks.


Inside OKAT CAS Academy, you'll have access to over 10 hours of real CAS assessment and therapy footage, giving you opportunities to train your clinical ear, recognise speech motor difficulties and develop your pattern recognition skills.


You'll also learn how I assess and treat CAS as speech demands increase — from more complex syllable shapes and consonant clusters to front-to-back and back-to-front movement sequences, three-element clusters, coarticulation within sentences and smooth transitions between words.


I'll show you how I select targets, adjust complexity, use successive approximations and make clinical decisions as children progress towards more accurate, fluent and connected speech.


See and hear what CAS looks and sounds like in real children — and learn how to take therapy beyond single words.






References


American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. (2007). Childhood apraxia of speech [Technical report]. https://www.asha.org/policy/TR2007-00278/


Case, J., & Grigos, M. I. (2020). A proposed model for identification of childhood apraxia of speech in young children. Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups, 5(4), 966-980. https://cjslpa.ca/files/2017_CJSLPA_Vol_41/No_01/CJSLPA_Vol_41_No_1_2017_Pukonen_et_al_10-32.pdf


Coplan, J., & Gleason, J. R. (1988). Unclear speech: Recognition and significance of unintelligible speech in preschool children. Pediatrics, 82(3), 447-452.


Hustad, K. C., Mahr, T. J., Natzke, P. E., & Rathouz, P. J. (2021). Developmental expectations for speech intelligibility in children. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 64(12), 4705-4721. https://share.google/C0M4lAvMAPTvRfAZJ


Strand, E. A., McCauley, R. J., Weigand, S. D., Stoeckel, R. E., & Baas, B. S. (2013). A motor speech assessment for children with severe speech disorders: Reliability and validity evidence. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 56(2), 505-520. https://doi.org/10.1044/1092-4388(2012/12-0094)

 

 

 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page